Oxfam America banner

Case in Point

No sooner do I comment on the overly credulous commentary being offered up by the techno-sphere regarding the ChromeOS announcement than I notice this wretchedly mis-titled article over at TechCrunch: “Google Is Keeping Chrome OS Simple. Maybe Too Simple.

Now, to be fair, this is Erick Schonfeld, and his deep abiding love of the Google-cock is well documented, so I shouldn’t be surprised. But quotes like this really take things to a new level:

Rather than support Android apps and other sorts of apps, there is only one kind of app Google is interested in: the Web app. Chrome OS is all about making Web apps the only apps you will ever need. Which kind of makes you wonder how long we’ll need Android apps, or iPhone apps for that matter, because you know it is only a matter of time before a phone comes out running on Chrome OS.

Seriously, Chrome web apps are now going to eradicate standalone Android or iPhone apps? The same web apps that Steve Jobs proposed two years ago and was widely, and rightly derided over? Web apps certainly have their place, but to even suggest that a phone running nothing but a web browser could even vaguely compete with native applications, be they Android or iPhone is laughable.

But this is Google we’re talking about. I’m honestly waiting for some “analysis” claiming that Google can warp the laws of physics. Maybe they can start by walking on water.



  • http://twitter.com/dssstrkl Paul Ward

    Wake me up when Google claims that they wrote and compiled Chrome OS using Chrome OS. Those of us who aren't dipshit bloggers still need our computers to do real work. Try running a fucking DNA amplification from a computer running a fucking web app some time.

  • Schuler Bob

    “The OS will support only a limited number of Google-blessed devices and peripherals, which is Google's way of ensuring reliability and security. “

    (http://arstechnica.com/open-source/news/2009/11...)

    Draconian! Draconian!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Matt-Stocum/10505280 Matt Stocum

    This all feels very Microsoftish, in that it seems that Google has two entirely separate OS divisions that just plain aren't talking to each other and don't have a consistent message. We have native apps on our cell phones, which, in theory, have always on internet connections, but are supposed to rely only on web apps on our computers, which may or may not have an internet connection. If there was a platform where I'd expect this to work, it would be a cell phone, and I still remember the collective groan when Steve said web apps were good enough.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Matt-Stocum/10505280 Matt Stocum

    I'm really curious how printing is going to work. Or are we not supposed to print documents anymore, since everything lives in THE CLOUD?

  • Sigivald

    Do you, uh, read your own blog?

    Because, these backgrounds, with the thin black text over them?

    Not so good for the legibility.

  • http://www.theangrydrunk.com The Angry Drunk

    I'm playing with some designs…deal with it.

blog comments powered by Disqus